"Haver" British usage: "to hem and haw." Scottish: "to maunder, to talk foolishly, to chatter, talk nonsense, to babble." Jewish: "a friend, chum, mate" - specifically someone willing to partner with you in grappling with truth and Word and life. Yep, I'm setting a high bar here...

Saturday, November 13, 2010

Adult Christianity

I came across some meditations by Richard Rohr that I've pieced together here. Interesting overlay on top of this year's Old Testament reading - and in light of many discussions and interactions over the past several years. I encourage you to read and sift and ponder and let Rohr haver with you a bit...of course, this will only really make sense to those in "the second half of their lives"... :)
In the first half of life you have to build your container which includes structure, family and law. These are the only things that control hormones and egos. If there is no limitation on the ego it self-destructs. We need sacred space, sacred time, and boundaries. If you don’t get structure when you are young, then later you become obsessed with law and rules.

When I was a chaplain at the Albuquerque jail there was a lot of talk about religion. Most people there had wasted the first half of life on alcohol, promiscuous sex and drugs. Their life had been chaos. They had an immense need for emotional purity and ego structure. Usually their religion was considered the only true religion, and they would invariably become very morally rigid about one or two select issues.

In the second half of life, you move toward the contents themselves, and your religion becomes a much broader sense of both morality and belonging. You have created your ego container and you just want to get to the real thing, the “new wine” as Jesus says, and not just the wineskins.

You must live and to some degree succeed in the tasks of the first half of life. You cannot fast-forward to the second half of life, spiritually speaking. Ego development is your first task, and then this “grain of wheat must die, or it remains just a grain of wheat” (John 12:24). You start by telling your children they are the center of the world and they are the best. God did this for the Jewish people in the Hebrew Scriptures, and this is what Jesus built on and passed on to us. It is not objectively true that we are “the best,” but it is psychologically and spiritually necessary to experience your “election” somehow. You need to have an ego to die to it and move beyond it. It is quite a paradox.

The final purpose of any idea of being special or chosen is to have the courage and the experience to communicate that “chosenness” to everyone else. It’s not just to advertise how saved and superior you are—which tends to be the common mistake.

Religion in a mature second half of life is not a moral matter or a superiority contest. It is a mystical matter where all questions of specialness have been answered at the deepest and most radical level—by God. So it is no longer my concern.

Paul says in Galatians 3 that the law will kill you, that the law leads to death, and only an experience of the Spirit has any saving power. Jesus says much the same with his mantra, “The law says, but I say" (Matthew 5:20-45). This has had little effect on the church recently.

Many Christians and many clergy are still trapped under the law and remain in the first half of life, spiritually speaking. This is not the gospel, but its most common counterfeit. You always fail if you’re under the criteria of the law because you can never attain something that you already have—namely your daughterhood and sonship in God. The law will send you on a wild goose chase that never ends and usually makes you more and more legalistic. Religion at this level becomes an eternal carrot on a stick held out in front of you. Unfortunately, we see this in many rigid and unhappy Christians. Their disappointment with God and themselves is visible to all but themselves, I am afraid. We can do so much better.

For most of the people I meet, the only way to get over the hump to the second half of life is some kind of suffering. Nothing else is strong enough to force us to let go of our ego structures and our old wineskins. We’re not ready at age twenty, although there are exceptions (like kids with cancer).

Some of our private salvation project has to fall apart and disappoint us. At that point the temptation is to go back and do the tasks of the first half of life with even greater diligence.

Organized Christianity in its Sunday form tends to encourage people to do the tasks of the first half of life over and over again (firming up the container instead of getting to the contents). The clergy do not question this because the container is what gives us a job. But it is also why many people become disillusioned by midlife, and also why we have the constant phenomenon of groups emerging on the side, like religious orders, hermits, and prayer and service groups where people actually try to live the message.

Up to the point where you fall in love with God, you haven’t yet met God. Religion is almost entirely cultural conformity and fear based. But “perfect love casts out all fear (1 John 4:18). If your motivation is still fear or shame based, then you are still building your container, which is necessary, but it does not demand any real love of God or neighbor yet.

Most of us begin with creating the skeleton, but it takes years and usually some suffering to find the meat, the muscle, and the real message of the Gospel. It is probably easiest to begin conservative, since liberals do not tend to respect the basic skeleton of faith or any limits to their seeming freedom.

In the second half of life you might look a little more like a liberal, but the real difference is that you have been overtaken by love and let go of fear. That is the meat, the muscle, and the message.

So how can we get to the second half of our own lives? We all know uptight men and women at 60 who still cannot let go and trust God or themselves. The secular person has no one to surrender to, so we can understand them being control freaks.

Christians supposedly do know a loving and trustworthy God, but they still do not entrust themselves to this God or others who are not just like them. Rigid and controlling people are almost always fear-based people. Only love thaws such coldness.

We each must fall into the hands of a living and loving God, sooner or later. It comes down to interior journeys of prayer, and leaps of faith where we learn to actively test and trust whether God is really with us, and whether God really cares. Only then can we deeply know that God is truly faithful and forgiving love—for us.

Many people are still living in a first-stage “beat up on myself” mode, as if this is supposed to please God. Unfortunately when you hate or fear yourself, you usually do the same to others—wives, husbands, family, coworkers, and neighbors.

In the second half of our spiritual lives, we do not need to prove, assert, or punish ourselves. We can freely and lovingly say “I am who I am.” Of course this grace has been granted after much shadowboxing and recognizing of one’s own failures. Afterwards you know that you are the same as everybody else, and we are all on this human journey together.

What you hate in other people is usually unrecognized and hated in yourself first. The only place to start therefore is with utter honesty and humility about yourself, but do not waste any time punishing yourself. That is the work of ego that always wants to judge everything up or down.

The soul compassionately sees everything in its wholeness and says “It is what it is.” From that radical acceptance comes real and deep change.

Adapted from Adult Christianity and How to Get There

9 comments:

  1. Christianity is living by Christ and under Gods law, not mans
    twitter.com/Johnsunol

    ReplyDelete
  2. I guess I'm not mystical enough to really understand what Richard Rohr was even saying...

    ReplyDelete
  3. Seems to me it's less about the law, and more about the law being satisfied by Him, not us. I fail to see how that's mystic...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Mystical was Rohr's word, not mine:) My comment about being mystical was just trying to understand what He said:

    "Religion in a mature second half of life is not a moral matter or a superiority contest. It is a mystical matter where all questions of specialness have been answered at the deepest and most radical level—by God. So it is no longer my concern."

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hm. Somehow I "myst" that, haha.

    I guess I can appreciate the balance presented here. Far too often, for me, it's easy to slip into Pharisee mode and try to ration out the grace for myself, and for others.

    Then God whacks me over the head with, humorously enough, the same book I was just reading... So I see the value in both the first and second halves of life.

    ReplyDelete
  6. :) So in your mind, what is the central or main idea that Mr. Rohr is trying to communicate? I'm trying not to misunderstand him, but it seems to me like he doesn't understand what law's purpose was. The law was not just simply "wineskins" (3rd paragraph), nor does any person have the ability to be successful at following any part of the law (4th paragraph). He seems to think otherwise.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm not sure, to be honest. I'm pondering it. But it does make me think of another author's words:

    "When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I put the ways of childhood behind me."

    ReplyDelete
  8. Josh, when he talks about "law" I'm not sure he's talking strictly about Torah. Look at the words he uses in the paragraph along with "law". Structure, Family and Rules. What it looks like to me is that he's talking about self (or community) imposed boundaries meant to help us "stay on track" and maybe more importantly to feel good about ourselves. I think he's saying that these are helpful but part of maturity is getting passed our dependence on them. And this is the mystical part. Real growth and maturity isn't something we control or truly understand.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Ok. I'm not sure at this point if anybody is going to read this, but I'll give it a shot anyway...
    This excerpt from Rohr is much to say about nothing. He talks about how to move from the first part of your life to the second part of your life without ever mentioning sin once! More importantly without ever mentioning the Gospel once! (The word gospel doesn't count...we are not saved by believing in the word: gospel) Which frankly is pretty astounding. God was so offended by our sin that He killed His own Son (Isaiah 53:10) in order to appease His wrath towards those He was going to save. We in our natural state are offensive to God! We in our natural state hate God-Romans 1:30- and Rohr is playing this game with the law like we need to move past it to greener pastures of grace. Now if we want to be saved we do have to have grace-no doubt- but he completely misunderstands and fails to articulate what the purpose of the law even is! Romans 3:19 says...

    "Now we know that whatever the law says it speaks to those who are under the law, so that every mouth may be stopped, and the whole world may be held accountable to God. For by works of the law no human being will be justified in his sight, since through the law comes knowledge of sin."

    God says that my people die for lack of revelation. We are dying today in the church. We are literally starving to death spiritually because we are running after all these teachers who tell us things that our itching ears want to hear. God is not glorified in us making much of ourselves. He is glorified when we make much of Him! He is glorified when Jesus Christ is heralded as the only sinless Savior and the only way to heaven. He is glorified when the Gospel is expounded not when some cheap imitation is given. Cheap imitations do not save. They only lead the person to hell. God desires men to be saved and loves it when people praise him and treasure him. I did not see that here. It's painfully missing especially in an article that professes to be adult christianity. The Gospel is not a mantra that gets you into the club! The Gospel was not meant to be believed for the first 5 minutes of our Christian life and then move on to "bigger and better" (and more mystical) things. There is nothing better than the Gospel! I was an enemy of God and God sent His Son into the world to live the life I was required to live by the law, and to die the death that I deserved to die! That is good news! I received this righteousness by faith alone--also good news because I don't have to work for it! But the best news is that I get Christ! I get Him! I get to spend eternity exploring the treasure that is Christ and that is what fuels the "second" part of my life!

    ReplyDelete